Film Critic
The Film Critic is a highly effective trout emerger for anglers who fish technical hatches and selective trout. It rides flush in the surface film and imitates mayflies in the most vulnerable stage, making it deadly during BWO, PMD, and other delicate hatch situations.
Imitates: Mayfly emergers in the film
Quick Reference
- Best Sizes
- #16-22
- Best Season
- Spring through fall
- Best Conditions
- Spring creeks, tailwaters, flat glides, and educated trout
- Water Temp
- 46-62°F
- Recommended Tippet
- 6X-7X
How to Rig It
Fish it alone to feeding trout or behind a tiny parachute dry for visibility.
How to Present It
Present it with a long leader and flawless drag-free drifts over rise forms.
Why It Works
The flush-riding profile looks like exactly what trout expect to see when they are locked on emergers.
History
Modern emerger designs like the Film Critic evolved to solve one problem: trout refusing flies that sit too high on the surface.
Pro Tip
This is a confidence pattern when trout are softly sipping and ignoring standard duns.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I fish a Film Critic?+
During selective mayfly hatches when trout are feeding in the surface film rather than taking high-riding dry flies.
Not sure if Film Critic is right today?
Get a fly recommendation based on live water temp, flow, sky, and time of day for any river in the US.
Open Fly Advisor
Map
Fly Guide