Starling and Herl
Starling and Herl is a tiny, elegant soft hackle trout fly that excels during midge, BWO, and small dark mayfly activity. It is especially effective for selective trout feeding in smooth water or when fish want a subtle, minimalist emerger profile.
Imitates: Tiny dark emergers, midges, and small mayfly pupae
Quick Reference
- Best Sizes
- #16-20
- Best Season
- Late fall through spring
- Best Conditions
- Tailouts, slick seams, spring creeks, and clear technical water
- Water Temp
- 38-58°F
- Recommended Tippet
- 6X-7X
How to Rig It
Fish it alone or as the top fly in a light soft-hackle pair for selective trout.
How to Present It
Use delicate drifts and gentle swings. This pattern is at its best when fish are feeding quietly rather than crashing bugs.
Why It Works
Its sparse starling feather and peacock herl body create movement and suggestion without bulk.
History
Traditional soft hackles like Starling and Herl remain important because they imitate the vulnerable emergence stage better than many heavier modern flies.
Pro Tip
Grease only the tippet above the fly if you want it to ride just under the film in spring-creek style water.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Starling and Herl good for selective trout?+
Yes. Its sparse, dark profile makes it one of the best traditional soft hackles for fussy trout.
Not sure if Starling and Herl is right today?
Get a fly recommendation based on live water temp, flow, sky, and time of day for any river in the US.
Open Fly Advisor
Map
Fly Guide